| Test | South Africa (1951-1964/65) |
| Main FC | Natal (1949/50-1965/66) |
| Other FC | South Africans (1951-1960) |
| | South Africa (1951-1964/65) |
| | DJ McGlew's XI (1951/52) |
| | South African Invitation XI (1959/60) |
| | South Africa Fezelas (1961) |
| | International XI (1961/62) |
| | Rest of South Africa (1964/65) |
| Miscellaneous | AD Nourse's XI (1950/51) |
| | South Africans (1951-1960) |
| | Natal (1955/56-1963/64) |
| | RA McLean's XI (1957/58) |
| | South Africa Fezelas (1961) |
| | International XI (1961/62) |
| | South of South Africa (1964/65) |
| | W Isaacs' XI (1966) |
| Scotland Cap | South Africans (1951) |
| Scotland Non-Cap | South Africa Fezelas (1961) |
