| Main FC | Jamaica (1901/02-1910/11) |
| Other FC | Jamaica Born (1901/02) |
| Halifax Cup | New York and Metropolitan District Cricket League (1915) |
| | Staten Island Cricket Club (1916-1917) |
| | Manor Field (1919-1921) |
| Miscellaneous | Canada (1905-1907) |
| | Jamaica North and South Side (1908/09) |
| | Jamaica (1910/11) |
| | Manhattan (1912) |
| | Richmond County (1912-1917) |
| | New York Veterans (1917-1925) |
| | All New York (1918-1933) |
| | New York Halifax Cup XI (1920) |
| | Manor Field (1922-1926) |
| | New York and New Jersey Cricket Association (1926) |
| | Fordham (USA) (1929) |
