| Other FC | American Born (1880-1883) |
| | Gentlemen of Philadelphia (1883-1891) |
| Halifax Cup | Merion (1880-1897) |
| Miscellaneous | Philadelphia (1872-1879) |
| | Merion (1876-1894) |
| | TD Phillips' XI (1876) |
| | Philadelphia Cricket Club (1877) |
| | Modocs (1877-1883) |
| | Gentlemen of Philadelphia (1879-1884) |
| | United States of America (1880-1891) |
| | University Barge Club (1882-1885) |
| | Staten Island Cricket Club (1882) |
| | All Philadelphia (1882-1885) |
| | JS Watts' XI (1883) |
| | Picked XI (1883) |
| | S Law's XI (1883-1885) |
| | R Toland's XI (1883) |
| | Philadelphia I Zingari (1884-1891) |
| | Incapables (USA) (1884) |
| | Wister's XI (1884) |
| | American I Zingari (1884) |
| | University of Pennsylvania Past (1886) |
| | RS Newhall's XI (1886) |
| | Germantown (1891) |
| Scotland Cap | Gentlemen of Philadelphia (1884) |
