| Other FC | Gentlemen of Philadelphia (1883-1885) |
| Halifax Cup | Girard (1881) |
| | Oxford (USA) (1882) |
| | Young America (1883-1888) |
| Miscellaneous | Oxford (USA) (1882-1885) |
| | United States of America (1882-1886) |
| | All Philadelphia (1882-1885) |
| | Young America (1883-1888) |
| | Picked XI (1883-1884) |
| | Gentlemen of Philadelphia (1883-1884) |
| | American I Zingari (1884) |
| | University of Pennsylvania Past (1886) |
| | Boston Athletic Association (1891) |
| | Staten Island Cricket Club (1893-1898) |
| | New York and District (1893) |
| | All New York (1894-1895) |
| | Staten Island and New Jersey Athletic Clubs (1894) |
| | Staten Island Cricket Club Summer XI (1895) |
