| Main FC | United States of America (1883) |
| Miscellaneous | Upper Canada College (1876-1880) |
| | Toronto (1877-1885) |
| | Carlton Club of Toronto (1879) |
| | Canada (1879-1888) |
| | Anglo-Canadians (1879) |
| | Ontario (1879) |
| | Chicago (1881-1898) |
| | Hamilton (1881-1888) |
| | Western Association (1882-1888) |
| | Canadian I Zingari (1883-1884) |
| | United States of America (1883) |
| | ER Ogden's XI (1884) |
| | Sawbones (1885) |
| | Ontario Association (1885) |
| | Gentlemen of Canada (1887-1888) |
| | Chicago Cricket Club (1890-1897) |
| Scotland Cap | Gentlemen of Canada (1887) |
| Scotland Non-Cap | Gentlemen of Canada (1887) |
