| Other FC | Gentlemen of Philadelphia (1885-1893) |
| | Philadelphia (1886) |
| Halifax Cup | Belmont (1884-1894) |
| Miscellaneous | Brooklyn (1882) |
| | Belmont Juniors (1883-1884) |
| | Belmont Second XI (1883-1884) |
| | Manhattan Second XI (1883-1889) |
| | Manhattan (1883-1889) |
| | Belmont (1883-1890) |
| | Young Philadelphia (1884-1885) |
| | University of Pennsylvania Past and Present (1885) |
| | University of Pennsylvania (1886-1889) |
| | University of Pennsylvania Present (1886) |
| | Belmont Veterans (1886) |
| | University of Pennsylvania Sophomores (1887) |
| | United States of America (1888) |
| | Gentlemen of Philadelphia (1888-1892) |
| | All Philadelphia (1893) |
| Scotland Cap | Gentlemen of Philadelphia (1889) |
