| Main FC | Somerset (1882-1885) |
| Miscellaneous | MC Kemp's XI (1881) |
| | Oxford University Freshmen (1881) |
| | Somerset (1881-1884) |
| | Toronto (1891-1905) |
| | Canada (1891-1907) |
| | London (Canada) (1891-1895) |
| | Western Ontario (1891-1894) |
| | Upper Canada College (1892-1893) |
| | Upper Canada College Past and Present (1892) |
| | Rosedale (1892) |
| | London Asylum (1892-1893) |
| | Gentlemen of Canada (1892-1894) |
| | Parkdale (1893) |
| | Ontario Association (1894) |
| | Canadian XI (1895) |
| | English Residents (1897) |
| | Ontario (1897) |
| | Eastern Canada (1898) |
| | McGill University (1899) |
