| Main FC | Marylebone Cricket Club (1859-1870) |
| Other FC | Gentlemen of Marylebone Cricket Club (1863-1868) |
| | I Zingari (1866) |
| Miscellaneous | Household Brigade (1858-1872) |
| | Infantry (1858) |
| | Marylebone Cricket Club (1858-1872) |
| | Lord Garlies' XI (1859) |
| | Earl of Winterton's XI (1859) |
| | Phoenix (1860) |
| | Knickerbockers (1862-1863) |
| | I Zingari (1862-1872) |
| | Na Shuler (1869-1870) |
| | Grenadier Guards Officers (1869) |
| | 2nd Battalion Grenadier Guards Officers (1869) |
| | 3rd Battalion Grenadier Guards (1869) |
| Scotland Cap | Marylebone Cricket Club (1865) |
