| Halifax Cup | Belmont (1884-1886) |
| | Germantown (1887) |
| Miscellaneous | Belmont Second XI (1884) |
| | Belmont (1884-1885) |
| | Foresters (1884) |
| | Gentlemen of Leisure (1884) |
| | Germantown Wanderers (1886) |
| | Germantown Second XI (1887) |
| | Germantown (1887) |
| | Kings County (1889-1891) |
| | All New York (1889-1898) |
| | Hamilton Club (1890) |
| | Cosmopolitan Club of New York (1890) |
| | New Jersey Athletic Club (1892-1898) |
| | Staten Island Athletic Club (1892-1894) |
| | New York and District (1893) |
| | Somersetshire (1894) |
| | Staten Island Cricket Club (1894) |
| | Roseville (USA) (1897) |
| | New York Cricket Club (1897) |
| | New Jersey Athletic Club A (1898) |
| | Knickerbocker Athletic Club A (1899) |
| | Knickerbocker Athletic Club (1899-1901) |
| | Knickerbocker Athletic Club Summer XI (1901) |
| | Richmond County (1912-1917) |
| | Manor Field (1917) |
