| 686 | NBF Mann | v Eastern Province | Ellis Park, Johannesburg | 1946/47 | f17372 |
| 633 | HJ Tayfield | v Natal | Kingsmead, Durban | 1954/55 | f20704 |
| 568 | JB Plimsoll | v Western Province | Newlands, Cape Town | 1946/47 | f17404 |
| 552 | TG Shaw | v Eastern Province | St George's Park, Port Elizabeth | 1988/89 | f38009 |
| 547 | HJ Tayfield | v Natal | Ellis Park, Johannesburg | 1951/52 | f19439 |
| 536 | A Tayfield | v Natal | Ellis Park, Johannesburg | 1948/49 | f18152 |
| 531 | TL Goddard | v Natal | New Wanderers Stadium, Johannesburg | 1956/57 | f21564 |
| 529 | DL Hobson | v Western Province | Newlands, Cape Town | 1977/78 | f31881 |
| 528 | MJ Macaulay | v Eastern Province | St George's Park, Port Elizabeth | 1977/78 | f31887 |
| 526 | JR Liddle | v Western Province | Newlands, Cape Town | 1955/56 | f21142 |
| 513 | SA Thwaits | v Western Province | Newlands, Cape Town | 1950/51 | f19011 |
| 510 | LW Payn | v Natal | Ellis Park, Johannesburg | 1946/47 | f17392 |
| 500 | GA Lohmann | v Western Province | Albert Park, Durban | 1894/95 | f4194 |
| 496 | LW Payn | v Natal | Ellis Park, Johannesburg | 1948/49 | f18152 |
| 488 | WH Douglas | v North Eastern Transvaal | Willowmoore Park Main Oval, Benoni | 1947/48 | f17820 |
| 482 | PM Dodds | v Natal | Kingsmead, Durban | 1958/59 | f22621 |
| 475 | KI Simmonds | v Western Province | PPC Newlands, Cape Town | 2021/22 | f60677 |
| 474 | HJ Tayfield | v Natal | Kingsmead, Durban | 1949/50 | f18545 |
| 474 | CW Henderson | v Western Province | New Wanderers Stadium, Johannesburg | 1998/99 | f43924 |
| 471 | HJ Tayfield | v Natal | Kingsmead, Durban | 1953/54 | f20257 |
| 464 | JE Waddington | v Griqualand West | De Beers Stadium, Kimberley | 1946/47 | f17351 |
| 464 | HJ Tayfield | v Natal | Kingsmead, Durban | 1955/56 | f21149 |
| 460 | HD Bromfield | v Western Province | Newlands, Cape Town | 1962/63 | f24616 |
| 456 | FJD Stokes-Waller | v North Eastern Transvaal | Willowmoore Park Main Oval, Benoni | 1947/48 | f17820 |
| 454 | CB van Ryneveld | v Western Province | Newlands, Cape Town | 1951/52 | f19471 |
| 450 | J Middleton | v Western Province | Old Wanderers, Johannesburg | 1903/04 | f6286 |
| 449 | VI Smith | v Natal | Kingsmead, Durban | 1954/55 | f20704 |
| 448 | HJ Tayfield | v Natal | Ellis Park, Johannesburg | 1950/51 | f19000 |
| 439 | JJ Kotze | v Western Province | Old Wanderers, Johannesburg | 1903/04 | f6286 |
| 432 | TG Shaw | v Eastern Province | St George's Park, Port Elizabeth | 1987/88 | f37335 |
| 428 | HD Bromfield | v Western Province | Newlands, Cape Town | 1960/61 | f23572 |
| 426 | PH Edmonds | v Eastern Province | St George's Park, Port Elizabeth | 1975/76 | f31012 |
| 424 | SH Martin | v Natal | Ellis Park, Johannesburg | 1946/47 | f17392 |
| 424 | EV Witte | v Western Province | Newlands, Cape Town | 1946/47 | f17404 |
| 423 | NH Hunter | v Border | Jan Smuts Ground, East London | 1964/65 | f25573 |
| 422 | HD Bromfield | v Western Province | Newlands, Cape Town | 1959/60 | f23032 |
| 420 | JBR Maile | v Western Province | Newlands, Cape Town | 1959/60 | f23032 |
| 416 | MA Hanley | v Western Province | Newlands, Cape Town | 1946/47 | f17404 |
| 416 | VI Smith | v Natal | Kingsmead, Durban | 1949/50 | f18545 |
| 416 | GA Chevalier | v Western Province | Newlands, Cape Town | 1970/71 | f28510 |
| 414 | AH McKinnon | v Eastern Province | St George's Park, Port Elizabeth | 1962/63 | f24623 |
| 414 | MB Minnaar | v Western Province | Newlands, Cape Town | 1985/86 | f36234 |
| 411 | AL Hobson | v Eastern Province | St George's Park, Port Elizabeth | 1988/89 | f38009 |
| 410 | GK Glover | v Kimberley | Old Wanderers, Johannesburg | 1890/91 | f3582 |
| 409 | JB Plimsoll | v Western Province | Newlands, Cape Town | 1945/46 | f17013 |
| 408 | LW Payn | v Natal | Kingsmead, Durban | 1949/50 | f18545 |
| 408 | CW Henderson | v Western Province | Newlands, Cape Town | 1999/00 | f44906 |
| 405 | GA Lohmann | v Western Province | Old Wanderers, Johannesburg | 1896/97 | f4627 |
| 405 | IDE Anderson | v Natal | Kingsmead, Durban | 1937/38 | f16059 |
| 402 | RE Davies | v Natal | Kingsmead, Durban | 1932/33 | f14128 |
| 402 | PR Adams | v Western Province | New Wanderers Stadium, Johannesburg | 1998/99 | f43924 |
