| 3-162 | NC McGarrell | West Indies v Zimbabwe | Harare Sports Club, Harare | 2001 |
| 5-133 | FH Edwards | West Indies v Zimbabwe | Harare Sports Club, Harare | 2003/04 |
| 1-131 | CD Collymore | West Indies v Zimbabwe | Harare Sports Club, Harare | 2003/04 |
| 2-110 | G Motie | West Indies v Zimbabwe | Queens Sports Club, Bulawayo | 2022/23 |
| 2-106 | OAC Banks | West Indies v Zimbabwe | Queens Sports Club, Bulawayo | 2003/04 |
| 4-105 | D Bishoo | West Indies v Zimbabwe | Queens Sports Club, Bulawayo | 2017/18 |
| 3-99 | CEL Stuart | West Indies v Zimbabwe | Harare Sports Club, Harare | 2001 |
| 0-93 | MI Black | West Indies v Zimbabwe | Harare Sports Club, Harare | 2001 |
| 1-86 | CL Hooper | West Indies v Zimbabwe | Harare Sports Club, Harare | 2001 |
| 1-85 | VC Drakes | West Indies v Zimbabwe | Harare Sports Club, Harare | 2003/04 |
| 2-82 | D Bishoo | West Indies v Zimbabwe | Queens Sports Club, Bulawayo | 2017/18 |
| 1-80 | RD King | West Indies v Zimbabwe | Harare Sports Club, Harare | 2001 |
| 5-79 | D Bishoo | West Indies v Zimbabwe | Queens Sports Club, Bulawayo | 2017/18 |
| 3-75 | AS Joseph | West Indies v Zimbabwe | Queens Sports Club, Bulawayo | 2022/23 |
| 2-74 | D Bishoo | West Indies v Zimbabwe | Queens Sports Club, Bulawayo | 2017/18 |
| 0-71 | RD King | West Indies v Zimbabwe | Queen's Park Oval, Port of Spain | 1999/00 |
| 4-70 | CD Collymore | West Indies v Zimbabwe | Queens Sports Club, Bulawayo | 2003/04 |
| 2-69 | FA Rose | West Indies v Zimbabwe | Sabina Park, Kingston | 1999/00 |
| 4-67 | VC Drakes | West Indies v Zimbabwe | Harare Sports Club, Harare | 2003/04 |
| 2-64 | ST Gabriel | West Indies v Zimbabwe | Queens Sports Club, Bulawayo | 2017/18 |
| 6-62 | G Motie | West Indies v Zimbabwe | Queens Sports Club, Bulawayo | 2022/23 |
| 2-61 | RL Chase | West Indies v Zimbabwe | Queens Sports Club, Bulawayo | 2017/18 |
| 2-59 | CD Collymore | West Indies v Zimbabwe | Harare Sports Club, Harare | 2003/04 |
| 5-59 | S Shillingford | West Indies v Zimbabwe | Windsor Park, Roseau | 2012/13 |
| 3-58 | S Shillingford | West Indies v Zimbabwe | Kensington Oval, Bridgetown | 2012/13 |
| 2-57 | M Dillon | West Indies v Zimbabwe | Queens Sports Club, Bulawayo | 2003/04 |
| 2-55 | JO Holder | West Indies v Zimbabwe | Queens Sports Club, Bulawayo | 2022/23 |
| 1-52 | FH Edwards | West Indies v Zimbabwe | Harare Sports Club, Harare | 2003/04 |
| 4-51 | RD King | West Indies v Zimbabwe | Queens Sports Club, Bulawayo | 2001 |
| 5-51 | RD King | West Indies v Zimbabwe | Sabina Park, Kingston | 1999/00 |
