| 1877 | | G Howitt |
| 1892 | | G Burton |
| 1897 | | T Hearne |
| 1899 | | J Phillips |
| 1903 | | JE West |
| 1905 | | G Burton |
| 1907 | | AE Trott |
| 1909 | | JE West |
| 1911 | | JT Rawlin |
| 1914 | | FA Tarrant |
| 1922 | | HR Murrell |
| 1923 | | EH Hendren |
| 1925 | | JW Hearne |
| 1927 | | HW Lee |
| 1929 | | FJ Durston |
| 1931 | | EH Hendren |
| 1932 | | JW Hearne |
| 1935 | | EH Hendren (Testimonial) |
| 1938 | | WFF Price |
| 1939 | | GE Hart (Joint benefit with JHA Hulme), JHA Hulme (Joint benefit with GE Hart) |
| 1948 | | LH Gray |
| 1949 | | DCS Compton |
| 1950 | | JM Sims |
| 1951 | | JDB Robertson |
| 1952 | | JA Young |
| 1953 | | SM Brown |
| 1954 | | LH Compton |
| 1955 | | HPH Sharp (Joint benefit with AW Thompson), AW Thompson (Joint benefit with HPH Sharp) |
| 1959 | | JDB Robertson |
| 1962 | | AE Moss |
| 1963 | | FJ Titmus |
| 1966 | | JT Murray (raised 8,010 pounds) |
| 1968 | | RW Hooker (raised 5,500 pounds) |
| 1969 | | WE Russell (raised 8,005 pounds) |
| 1970 | | PH Parfitt (raised 10,000 pounds) |
| 1972 | | JSE Price (raised 9,810 pounds) |
| 1973 | | FJ Titmus (raised 6,196 pounds) |
| 1974 | | AH Latchman (Testimonial. Raised 1,486 pounds) |
| 1975 | | JT Murray |
| 1976 | | MJ Smith (raised 20,000 pounds) |
| 1977 | | CT Radley (raised 26,000 pounds) |
| 1978 | | JM Brearley (raised 31,000 pounds) |
| 1979 | | NG Featherstone (raised 30,000 pounds) |
| 1981 | | D Bennett (Testimonial) |
| 1982 | | MWW Selvey |
| 1983 | | PH Edmonds (raised 80,000 pounds) |
| 1984 | | GD Barlow |
| 1985 | | WW Daniel |
| 1986 | | JE Emburey |
| 1987 | | CT Radley |
| 1988 | | MW Gatting |
| 1989 | | RO Butcher |
| 1990 | | PR Downton |
| 1991 | | SP Hughes |
| 1992 | | Middlesex Youth Trust |
| 1993 | | NG Cowans |
| 1994 | | NF Williams |
| 1995 | | JE Emburey (Testimonial) |
| 1996 | | MW Gatting |
| 1997 | | ARC Fraser |
| 1998 | | KR Brown |
| 1999 | | PCR Tufnell |
| 2000 | | MR Ramprakash |
| 2002 | | PN Weekes |
| 2003 | | MA Roseberry (Testimonial) |
| 2007 | | DC Nash |
| 2008 | | OA Shah |
| 2009 | | AJ Strauss |
