| 234 | ER Mayne | East Melbourne v Carlton | East Melbourne Cricket Ground, Melbourne | vca1681 |
| 208* | AG Moyes | Essendon v Richmond | Windy Hill, Melbourne | vca1658 |
| 189 | MD Hotchin | St Kilda v Northcote | St Kilda Cricket Ground, Melbourne | vca1694 |
| 168 | TIB Horan | St Kilda v Prahran | St Kilda Cricket Ground, Melbourne | vca1695 |
| 154* | AEV Hartkopf | Northcote v Richmond | Richmond Cricket Ground, Melbourne | vca1643 |
| 153* | F Vaughan | Melbourne v Fitzroy | Fitzroy Cricket Ground, Melbourne | vca1628 |
| 151 | HCA Sandford | Melbourne v Collingwood | Melbourne Cricket Ground, Melbourne | vca1654 |
| 136* | CB Willis | Prahran v Melbourne | Toorak Park, Melbourne | vca1693 |
| 135 | AE Brown | Collingwood v Essendon | Windy Hill, Melbourne | vca1640 |
| 135* | WJG Woodbury | Northcote v Carlton | Westgarth Street Oval, Melbourne | vca1665 |
| 133 | WH Bailey | University v Melbourne | University Oval, Melbourne | vca1692 |
| 132 | J Ryder | Collingwood v Melbourne | Melbourne Cricket Ground, Melbourne | vca1654 |
| 131 | LA Cody | Fitzroy v North Melbourne | North Melbourne Cricket Ground, Melbourne | vca1689 |
| 130 | MD Hotchin | St Kilda v Prahran | St Kilda Cricket Ground, Melbourne | vca1695 |
| 125 | EK Tolhurst | Melbourne v University | University Oval, Melbourne | vca1692 |
| 122 | BL Cohen | St Kilda v Northcote | St Kilda Cricket Ground, Melbourne | vca1694 |
| 120 | GA Davies | Essendon v East Melbourne | East Melbourne Cricket Ground, Melbourne | vca1663 |
| 115 | CB Willis | Prahran v St Kilda | St Kilda Cricket Ground, Melbourne | vca1695 |
| 112 | JL Keating | Collingwood v Essendon | Windy Hill, Melbourne | vca1640 |
| 112 | C Kiernan | Fitzroy v South Melbourne | South Melbourne Cricket Ground, Melbourne | vca1667 |
| 111 | AW Lampard | Prahran v Richmond | Toorak Park, Melbourne | vca1655 |
| 109 | BL Cohen | St Kilda v Collingwood | St Kilda Cricket Ground, Melbourne | vca1668 |
| 108 | JL Keating | Collingwood v Prahran | Victoria Park, Melbourne | vca1657 |
| 108 | MD Hotchin | St Kilda v Northcote | Westgarth Street Oval, Melbourne | vca1661 |
| 107 | EV Carroll | Northcote v East Melbourne | East Melbourne Cricket Ground, Melbourne | vca1646 |
| 107 | A Kenny | South Melbourne v North Melbourne | South Melbourne Cricket Ground, Melbourne | vca1648 |
| 106 | JL Ellis | Prahran v Richmond | Toorak Park, Melbourne | vca1655 |
| 106 | EL Carroll | Essendon v University | University Oval, Melbourne | vca1674 |
| 105 | CB Willis | Prahran v Essendon | Windy Hill, Melbourne | vca1682 |
| 104 | J Ryder | Collingwood v East Melbourne | Victoria Park, Melbourne | vca1669 |
| 102 | LE Downs | Carlton v South Melbourne | South Melbourne Cricket Ground, Melbourne | vca1662 |
| 100* | FC Yeomans | Northcote v University | Westgarth Street Oval, Melbourne | vca1630 |
| 100* | F Vaughan | Melbourne v Richmond | Melbourne Cricket Ground, Melbourne | vca1647 |
| 100* | AJW Lansdown | Fitzroy v Richmond | Richmond Cricket Ground, Melbourne | vca1685 |
