| 189 | AEV Hartkopf | Northcote v Melbourne | Westgarth Street Oval, Melbourne | vca1910 |
| 178* | EV Carroll | Northcote v University | Westgarth Street Oval, Melbourne | vca1841 |
| 151 | LD Ferguson | St Kilda v Northcote | Melbourne Cricket Ground, Melbourne | vca1912 |
| 142* | WG Sutherland | Carlton v Melbourne | Albert Ground, Melbourne | vca1840 |
| 142 | SJ Hastings | Carlton v South Melbourne | Princes Park, Melbourne | vca1880 |
| 141 | RL Park | South Melbourne v Hawthorn-East Melbourne | South Melbourne Cricket Ground, Melbourne | vca1901 |
| 139 | WM Woodfull | South Melbourne v Fitzroy | Fitzroy Cricket Ground, Melbourne | vca1876 |
| 138* | AA Charlesworth | Northcote v South Melbourne | South Melbourne Cricket Ground, Melbourne | vca1891 |
| 135 | FA Baring | Hawthorn-East Melbourne v Essendon | Windy Hill, Melbourne | vca1875 |
| 135* | VC Monohan | Collingwood v North Melbourne | Victoria Park, Melbourne | vca1898 |
| 128 | WH Bailey | University v Carlton | Princes Park, Melbourne | vca1904 |
| 125 | TH Purvis | South Melbourne v Northcote | South Melbourne Cricket Ground, Melbourne | vca1891 |
| 125 | WH Ponsford | St Kilda v North Melbourne | St Kilda Cricket Ground, Melbourne | vca1897 |
| 122* | SJ Hastings | Carlton v Collingwood | Princes Park, Melbourne | vca1874 |
| 122* | AE Brown | Collingwood v North Melbourne | Victoria Park, Melbourne | vca1898 |
| 116* | AE Brown | Collingwood v Northcote | Westgarth Street Oval, Melbourne | vca1883 |
| 114* | NF Mitchell | University v Melbourne | Melbourne Cricket Ground, Melbourne | vca1888 |
| 113 | WH Ponsford | St Kilda v South Melbourne | St Kilda Cricket Ground, Melbourne | vca1848 |
| 110 | AE Brown | Collingwood v Carlton | Princes Park, Melbourne | vca1874 |
| 104* | TJ Bayliss | Richmond v North Melbourne | Richmond Cricket Ground, Melbourne | vca1878 |
| 104* | AD Kelso | Hawthorn-East Melbourne v South Melbourne | South Melbourne Cricket Ground, Melbourne | vca1901 |
| 100 | GEJ Healy | Prahran v Essendon | Windy Hill, Melbourne | vca1851 |
| 100 | EL Spencer | North Melbourne v University | University Oval, Melbourne | vca1867 |
| 100* | RE Allison | South Melbourne v Hawthorn-East Melbourne | South Melbourne Cricket Ground, Melbourne | vca1901 |
