| 179 | LW Levin | St Kilda v Northcote | St Kilda Cricket Ground, Melbourne | vca1971 |
| 160 | OB Jenkin | Essendon v Collingwood | Windy Hill, Melbourne | vca1967 |
| 159* | RL Park | South Melbourne v Fitzroy | Fitzroy Cricket Ground, Melbourne | vca1963 |
| 149* | A Kenny | South Melbourne v Carlton | South Melbourne Cricket Ground, Melbourne | vca1970 |
| 148 | J Ryder | Collingwood v Carlton | Victoria Park, Melbourne | vca1943 |
| 145 | NF Mitchell | University v Northcote | Westgarth Street Oval, Melbourne | vca1966 |
| 144* | RN Ellis | St Kilda v Northcote | St Kilda Cricket Ground, Melbourne | vca1971 |
| 143* | VC Monohan | Collingwood v North Melbourne | Victoria Park, Melbourne | vca1932 |
| 140 | CAH Sindrey | Richmond v University | Richmond Cricket Ground, Melbourne | vca1924 |
| 140* | HSTL Hendry | Melbourne v South Melbourne | South Melbourne Cricket Ground, Melbourne | vca1948 |
| 137* | FR Huntington | Northcote v University | Westgarth Street Oval, Melbourne | vca1966 |
| 133 | JR Hasker | University v Northcote | Westgarth Street Oval, Melbourne | vca1966 |
| 131 | HC Lansdown | Fitzroy v South Melbourne | Fitzroy Cricket Ground, Melbourne | vca1963 |
| 128* | J Ryder | Collingwood v Hawthorn-East Melbourne | Glenferrie Oval, Melbourne | vca1956 |
| 118 | WM Woodfull | Carlton v Collingwood | Victoria Park, Melbourne | vca1943 |
| 117 | J Ryder | Collingwood v Fitzroy | Fitzroy Cricket Ground, Melbourne | vca1937 |
| 117 | TN Leonard | South Melbourne v Carlton | South Melbourne Cricket Ground, Melbourne | vca1970 |
| 116 | GA Coppock | Collingwood v Essendon | Windy Hill, Melbourne | vca1967 |
| 112 | CA Fergie | Melbourne v Essendon | Melbourne Cricket Ground, Melbourne | vca1938 |
| 110 | GEJ Healy | Prahran v University | University Oval, Melbourne | vca1942 |
| 108 | WH Ponsford | St Kilda v Prahran | St Kilda Cricket Ground, Melbourne | vca1980 |
| 107* | J Ryder | Collingwood v Melbourne | Victoria Park, Melbourne | vca1920 |
| 107 | AW Lampard | St Kilda v Essendon | Windy Hill, Melbourne | vca1933 |
| 107 | GA Coppock | Collingwood v Fitzroy | Fitzroy Cricket Ground, Melbourne | vca1937 |
| 104* | AE Brown | Collingwood v Richmond | Victoria Park, Melbourne | vca1962 |
| 101* | HJ Richardson | Richmond v Northcote | Westgarth Street Oval, Melbourne | vca1940 |
| 101* | AJW Lansdown | Fitzroy v Essendon | Windy Hill, Melbourne | vca1955 |
| 101 | AO Thomson | Richmond v Hawthorn-East Melbourne | Glenferrie Oval, Melbourne | vca1979 |
| 100* | GEJ Healy | Prahran v Essendon | Windy Hill, Melbourne | vca1921 |
| 100* | FC Yeomans | St Kilda v Prahran | Toorak Park, Melbourne | vca1946 |
