| 5 | N Boje | Eastern Province v Free State | 1996/97 | f42989 |
| 5 | LJ Koen | Free State v Eastern Province | 1996/97 | f42989 |
| 5 | GFJ Liebenberg | North West v Free State | 2000/01 | f45436 |
| 5 | I Khan | Eagles v Dolphins | 2007/08 | f50576 |
| 5 | HH Dippenaar | Lions v Eagles | 2008/09 | f50997 |
| 5 | A Mgijima | Free State v Western Province | 2010/11 | f52732 |
| 5 | GM Thomson | Free State v Northerns | 2016/17 | f57813 |
| 5 | JL du Plooy | Easterns v Free State | 2017/18 | f58413 |
| 5 | TI Ntuli | Boland v Free State | 2019/20 | f59695 |
| 4 | CF Craven | Northern Transvaal v Orange Free State | 1993/94 | f40930 |
| 4 | AM Bacher | Orange Free State v Transvaal | 1994/95 | f41610 |
| 4 | KC Jackson | Free State v Boland | 1995/96 | f41977 |
| 4 | LJ Koen | Free State v Eastern Province | 1995/96 | f42284 |
| 4 | VVS Laxman | Free State v Indians | 1996/97 | f42842 |
| 4 | LJ Wilkinson | Natal v Free State | 1997/98 | f43414 |
| 4 | AM Bacher | Free State v Gauteng | 1998/99 | f43942 |
| 4 | PJL Radley | Border v Free State | 1998/99 | f44042 |
| 4 | JL Ontong | Free State v Boland | 1999/00 | f44577 |
| 4 | GFJ Liebenberg | Border v Free State | 1999/00 | f44797 |
| 4 | AI Gait | Border v Free State | 1999/00 | f44797 |
| 4 | ND McKenzie | Free State v Northerns | 1999/00 | f44851 |
| 4 | HD Ackerman | India A v South Africa A | 2001/02 | f46559 |
| 4 | JA Beukes | KwaZulu-Natal v Free State | 2002/03 | f46796 |
| 4 | JA Beukes | Griqualand West v Free State | 2002/03 | f46811 |
| 4 | GFJ Liebenberg | Boland v Free State | 2003/04 | f47532 |
| 4 | M Morkel | Eagles v Titans | 2005/06 | f49224 |
| 4 | JA Rudolph | Dolphins v Eagles | 2006/07 | f49711 |
| 4 | DJ Jacobs | New Zealanders v South African Invitation XI | 2007/08 | f50262 |
| 4 | HH Dippenaar | Titans v Eagles | 2007/08 | f50462 |
| 4 | F du Plessis | Eagles v Titans | 2008/09 | f51527 |
| 4 | LN Mosena | KwaZulu-Natal v Free State | 2009/10 | f52351 |
| 4 | VB van Jaarsveld | Knights v Dolphins | 2011/12 | f53708 |
| 4 | C Chetty | Knights v Dolphins | 2011/12 | f53708 |
| 4 | JM Kemp | Knights v Cape Cobras | 2012/13 | f54588 |
| 4 | S Burger | Free State v KwaZulu-Natal Inland | 2013/14 | f55007 |
| 4 | RR Hendricks | England Lions v South Africa A | 2014/15 | f56094 |
| 4 | MN Erlank | Warriors v Knights | 2016/17 | f57710 |
| 4 | J Draai | Eastern Province v Free State | 2016/17 | f57742 |
| 4 | JL du Plooy | Boland v Free State | 2017/18 | f58360 |
| 4 | TB de Bruyn | Dolphins v Knights | 2017/18 | f58510 |
| 4 | AR Easwaran | South Africa A v India A | 2021/22 | f60628 |
