| Extras |
| 50 | Accrington v Colne | The Horsfield, Colne | 2008 |
| 48 | Accrington v East Lancashire | Thorneyholme Road, Accrington | 2016 |
| 48 | Accrington v Great Harwood | The iMEP Arena, Accrington | 2024 |
| 46 | Accrington v Colne | Thorneyholme Road, Accrington | 1991 |
| 45 | Accrington v East Lancashire | The iMEP Arena, Accrington | 2024 |
| 43 | Accrington v Colne | The Horsfield, Colne | 2014 |
| 42 | Accrington v Church | Thorneyholme Road, Accrington | 2013 |
| 42 | Accrington v Littleborough | Thorneyholme Road, Accrington | 2018 |
| 42 | Accrington v East Lancashire | Alexandra Meadows, Blackburn | 2025 |
| 41 | Accrington v Bacup | Thorneyholme Road, Accrington | 2013 |
| 40 | Accrington v East Lancashire | Alexandra Meadows, Blackburn | 2024 |
| 39 | Accrington v Crompton | The Property Shop Arena, Thorneyholme Road, Accrington | 2019 |
| 38 | Accrington v Enfield | Dill Hall Lane, Enfield | 2008 |
| 37 | Accrington v Rawtenstall | Thorneyholme Road, Accrington | 1985 |
| 36 | Accrington v Ramsbottom | Acre Bottom, Ramsbottom | 1989 |
| 36 | Accrington v Bacup | Lanehead, Bacup | 2010 |
| 36 | Accrington v Haslingden | Thorneyholme Road, Accrington | 2016 |
| 35 | Accrington v Colne | The Horsfield, Colne | 1992 |
| 35 | Accrington v Burnley | Turf Moor, Burnley | 2011 |
| 35 | Accrington v Haslingden | Bentgate, Haslingden | 2011 |
| 35 | Accrington v Rawtenstall | Thorneyholme Road, Accrington | 2013 |
| 35 | Accrington v Nelson | Thorneyholme Road, Accrington | 2013 |
| 35 | Accrington v Bacup | Thorneyholme Road, Accrington | 2015 |
| 35 | Accrington v Nelson | Seedhill, Nelson | 2017 |
| 35 | Accrington v Rishton | The Property Shop Arena, Thorneyholme Road, Accrington | 2021 |
| 35 | Accrington v Church | The Property Shop Arena, Thorneyholme Road, Accrington | 2022 |
| 34 | Accrington v Haslingden | Thorneyholme Road, Accrington | 2008 |
| 34 | Accrington v Colne | Thorneyholme Road, Accrington | 2010 |
| 34 | Accrington v Rawtenstall | The Worswick Memorial Ground, Rawtenstall | 2011 |
| 34 | Accrington v Bacup | Lanehead, Bacup | 2014 |
| 34 | Accrington v Bacup | Thorneyholme Road, Accrington | 2014 |
| 34 | Accrington v Great Harwood | Cliffe Park, Great Harwood | 2017 |
| 34 | Accrington v Nelson | Seedhill, Nelson | 2022 |
| 33 | Accrington v Enfield | Thorneyholme Road, Accrington | 1994 |
| 33 | Accrington v Burnley | Turf Moor, Burnley | 2000 |
| 33 | Accrington v Nelson | Thorneyholme Road, Accrington | 2012 |
| 33 | Accrington v Haslingden | Bentgate, Haslingden | 2014 |
| 33 | Accrington v Milnrow | Ladyhouse, Milnrow | 2018 |
| 32 | Accrington v Nelson | Thorneyholme Road, Accrington | 1915 |
| 32 | Accrington v Lowerhouse | Liverpool Road, Lowerhouse | 2006 |
| 32 | Accrington v Colne | The Horsfield, Colne | 2010 |
| 31 | Accrington v Colne | The Horsfield, Colne | 1990 |
| 31 | Accrington v Nelson | Seedhill, Nelson | 1999 |
| 31 | Accrington v Enfield | Thorneyholme Road, Accrington | 2008 |
| 31 | Accrington v Colne | Thorneyholme Road, Accrington | 2011 |
| 31 | Accrington v Bacup | Lanehead, Bacup | 2012 |
| 31 | Accrington v Ramsbottom | Acre Bottom, Ramsbottom | 2012 |
| 31 | Accrington v Todmorden | Thorneyholme Road, Accrington | 2013 |
| 31 | Accrington v Enfield | Thorneyholme Road, Accrington | 2013 |
| 31 | Accrington v Todmorden | The Property Shop Arena, Thorneyholme Road, Accrington | 2019 |
| 31 | Accrington v Ramsbottom | Acre Bottom, Ramsbottom | 2024 |
| 31 | Accrington v Enfield | Dill Hall Lane, Enfield | 2025 |
| 30 | Accrington v Rishton | Thorneyholme Road, Accrington | 1988 |
| 30 | Accrington v Colne | Thorneyholme Road, Accrington | 2008 |
| 30 | Accrington v Rishton | Thorneyholme Road, Accrington | 2009 |
| 30 | Accrington v Church | Blackburn Road, Oswaldtwistle | 2013 |
| 30 | Accrington v Rawtenstall | Thorneyholme Road, Accrington | 2014 |
| 30 | Accrington v Clitheroe | The Property Shop Arena, Thorneyholme Road, Accrington | 2019 |
| 30 | Accrington v Nelson | Seedhill, Nelson | 2024 |
| 30 | Accrington v Greenmount | Brandlesholme Road, Greenmount | 2025 |
