| 246 | AR Keath | Knowle and Dorridge v Berkswell | Station Road, Dorridge | 2015 |
| 217 | JJNP Bhula | Barnards Green v West Bromwich Dartmouth | Sandwell Park, West Bromwich | 2024 |
| 197* | EJ Pollock | Barnt Green v Kenilworth Wardens | Cherry Hill Road, Barnt Green | 2019 |
| 194 | TRH Burton | Walmley v West Bromwich Dartmouth | The John Findlay Memorial Ground, Walmley | 2015 |
| 194 | DKH Mitchell | Brockhampton v Dorridge | The Parks, Brockhampton | 2017 |
| 193 | VB van Jaarsveld | Moseley v Coventry and North Warwickshire | Scorers, Shirley | 2007 |
| 192* | GH Worker | Knowle and Dorridge v Kidderminster Victoria | Chester Road North, Kidderminster | 2017 |
| 192 | KHD Barker | Moseley v Shrewsbury | London Road, Shrewsbury | 2023 |
| 190 | CW Boroughs | Brockhampton v Leamington | The Parks, Brockhampton | 2012 |
| 190 | AJ Phillips | Knowle and Dorridge v Wolverhampton | Station Road, Dorridge | 2013 |
| 186 | GD Wright | Himley v West Bromwich Dartmouth | Sandwell Park, West Bromwich | 2013 |
| 186* | TR Cornall | Ombersley v Knowle and Dorridge | Main Road, Ombersley | 2023 |
| 183 | GH Worker | Knowle and Dorridge v Brockhampton | The Parks, Brockhampton | 2017 |
| 182* | AJ Phillips | Knowle and Dorridge v Brockhampton | The Parks, Brockhampton | 2017 |
| 180* | AJ Phillips | Knowle and Dorridge v Walmley | Station Road, Dorridge | 2016 |
| 175 | K Ali | West Bromwich Dartmouth v Kidderminster Victoria | Sandwell Park, West Bromwich | 2011 |
| 175* | TRH Burton | Walmley v Leamington | Arlington Avenue, Leamington Spa | 2016 |
| 173* | NV Humphrey | Stratford-upon-Avon v Walsall | Swans Nest Lane, Stratford-upon-Avon | 1999 |
| 173 | GH Worker | Knowle and Dorridge v West Bromwich Dartmouth | Station Road, Dorridge | 2017 |
| 171* | GG Wagg | Coventry and North Warwickshire v Himley | Bulls Head Ground, Coventry | 2004 |
| 171 | AS Basra | Berkswell v Shrewsbury | Meeting House Lane, Balsall Common | 2025 |
| 169 | C Jonker | Walsall v West Bromwich Dartmouth | Sandwell Park, West Bromwich | 2011 |
| 169 | EJ Foster | Shrewsbury v Kidderminster Victoria | London Road, Shrewsbury | 2013 |
| 169 | CR Wood | Kidderminster Victoria v Leamington | Arlington Avenue, Leamington Spa | 2016 |
| 169* | GH Worker | Knowle and Dorridge v Kidderminster Victoria | Station Road, Dorridge | 2017 |
| 165 | T Kohler-Cadmore | Himley v Walsall | Stourbridge Road, Himley | 2014 |
| 165 | CG Benjamin | Smethwick v Barnards Green | North End Lane, Malvern | 2024 |
| 164* | MM Ali | West Bromwich Dartmouth v Shifnal | Sandwell Park, West Bromwich | 2008 |
| 162 | RM Yates | Moseley v Barnt Green | Cherry Hill Road, Barnt Green | 2022 |
| 160* | CR Wood | Kidderminster Victoria v Knowle and Dorridge | Station Road, Dorridge | 2017 |
| 160 | Rizwan Hussain | Ombersley v Shrewsbury | London Road, Shrewsbury | 2023 |
| 159 | OJP Haley | Knowle and Dorridge v Smethwick | Station Road, Dorridge | 2019 |
| 159 | JP Harrison | Kenilworth Wardens v Knowle and Dorridge | Glasshouse Park, Kenilworth | 2023 |
| 158* | DL Maddy | Berkswell v Kenilworth Wardens | Meeting House Lane, Balsall Common | 2016 |
| 158* | BL D'Oliveira | Ombersley v Brockhampton | The Parks, Brockhampton | 2017 |
| 158 | EJ Pollock | Barnt Green v Kidderminster Victoria | Chester Road North, Kidderminster | 2017 |
| 158 | EJ Pollock | Barnt Green v Smethwick | Cherry Hill Road, Barnt Green | 2022 |
| 158* | SSE Gumbs | Berkswell v Barnards Green | Meeting House Lane, Balsall Common | 2025 |
| 157 | GH Worker | Knowle and Dorridge v Kenilworth Wardens | Glasshouse Park, Kenilworth | 2017 |
| 157* | Gurender Singh | Smethwick v Barnt Green | Broomfield, Smethwick | 2021 |
| 156* | HR Jones | West Bromwich Dartmouth v Moseley | Sandwell Park, West Bromwich | 2006 |
| 156 | C Jonker | Walsall v Knowle and Dorridge | Gorway, Walsall | 2011 |
| 156* | TP Milnes | Berkswell v Kidderminster Victoria | Chester Road North, Kidderminster | 2017 |
| 155 | EJ Foster | Shrewsbury v Walmley | London Road, Shrewsbury | 2009 |
| 155 | W Parton | Shrewsbury v Walsall | London Road, Shrewsbury | 2019 |
| 154* | MJ Hill | Kidderminster Victoria v Kenilworth Wardens | Chester Road North, Kidderminster | 2016 |
| 154* | D Khatri | Smethwick v Knowle and Dorridge | Station Road, Dorridge | 2024 |
| 152 | MW Hill | Knowle and Dorridge v Walmley | The John Findlay Memorial Ground, Walmley | 2014 |
| 152 | MT Best | Berkswell v Barnt Green | Cherry Hill Road, Barnt Green | 2015 |
| 152 | S Stenning | Knowle and Dorridge v Kenilworth Wardens | Station Road, Dorridge | 2019 |
| 152* | RM Edavalath | Barnards Green v Wolverhampton | North End Lane, Malvern | 2025 |
| 151* | RM Yates | Moseley v Dorridge | Scorers, Shirley | 2018 |
| 151* | Abdullah Awan | Moseley v Walsall | Gorway, Walsall | 2021 |
| 150 | TP Singh | Himley v Shrewsbury | Stourbridge Road, Himley | 2010 |
| 150 | A Javid | West Bromwich Dartmouth v Ombersley | Sandwell Park, West Bromwich | 2015 |
| 150 | BL D'Oliveira | Ombersley v Walsall | Gorway, Walsall | 2016 |
| 150 | EJ Pollock | Barnt Green v Kenilworth Wardens | Glasshouse Park, Kenilworth | 2019 |
| 150* | J Banton | Barnt Green v Ombersley | Cherry Hill Road, Barnt Green | 2023 |
| 150 | MG Pardoe | Halesowen v Berkswell | Seth Somers Park, Halesowen | 2024 |
| 150 | OJ Walker | Himley v Moseley | Stourbridge Road, Himley | 2025 |
