| A Shaw | for Nottinghamshire | County Ground, Derby | 1875 | f1910 |
| W Pearce | for Kent | County Ground, Derby | 1878 | f2120 |
| RG Barlow | for Lancashire | Old Trafford, Manchester | 1879 | f2206 |
| RG Barlow | for Lancashire | County Ground, Derby | 1881 | f2402 |
| A Rylott | for Marylebone Cricket Club | Lord's Cricket Ground, St John's Wood | 1884 | f2751 |
| F Martin | for Marylebone Cricket Club | Lord's Cricket Ground, St John's Wood | 1895 | f4213 |
| JT Brown | for Yorkshire | County Ground, Derby | 1896 | f4475 |
| S Haigh | for Yorkshire | Park Avenue Cricket Ground, Bradford | 1897 | f4792 |
| TW Hayward | for Surrey | Queen's Park, Chesterfield | 1899 | f5099 |
| WH Lockwood | for Surrey | Kennington Oval, Kennington | 1901 | f5528 |
| JR Gunn | for Nottinghamshire | Queen's Park, Chesterfield | 1904 | f6386 |
| W Shipman | for Leicestershire | Aylestone Road, Leicester | 1909 | f7801 |
| C Blythe | for Kent | Bat and Ball Ground, Gravesend | 1910 | f8028 |
| J Bullough | for Lancashire | County Ground, Derby | 1914 | f9178 |
| A Drake | for Yorkshire | Queen's Park, Chesterfield | 1914 | f9183 |
| B Tremlin | for Essex | County Ground, Derby | 1914 | f9215 |
| JD Tyldesley | for Lancashire | Old Trafford, Manchester | 1920 | f9641 |
| W Rhodes | for Yorkshire | County Ground, Derby | 1920 | f9673 |
| JJ Bridges | for Somerset | The Town Ground, Burton-on-Trent | 1924 | f10903 |
| RK Tyldesley | for Lancashire | County Ground, Derby | 1929 | f12624 |
| J Langridge | for Sussex | County Ground, Derby | 1939 | f16570 |
| VE Jackson | for Leicestershire | County Ground, Derby | 1946 | f17076 |
| VI Smith | for South Africans | County Ground, Derby | 1947 | f17620 |
| F Ridgway | for Kent | Cheriton Road Sports Ground, Folkestone | 1951 | f19278 |
| VS Munden | for Leicestershire | Bath Grounds, Ashby-de-la-Zouch | 1953 | f20118 |
| DG A'Court | for Gloucestershire | Wagon Works Ground, Gloucester | 1961 | f23825 |
| N Gifford | for Worcestershire | Queen's Park, Chesterfield | 1965 | f25923 |
| A Buss | for Sussex | County Ground, Hove | 1965 | f25947 |
| R Harman | for Surrey | Rutland Recreation Ground, Ilkeston | 1968 | f27370 |
| RGD Willis | for Warwickshire | Edgbaston, Birmingham | 1972 | f29325 |
| PB Clift | for Leicestershire | Queen's Park, Chesterfield | 1985 | f35853 |
| PW Jarvis | for Yorkshire | Queen's Park, Chesterfield | 1985 | f35864 |
| TA Merrick | for Warwickshire | County Ground, Derby | 1988 | f37633 |
| WJ Holdsworth | for Australians | County Ground, Derby | 1993 | f40588 |
| PJ Hartley | for Yorkshire | Queen's Park, Chesterfield | 1995 | f41735 |
| DW Headley | for Kent | County Ground, Derby | 1996 | f42507 |
| GP Butcher | for Surrey | The Foster's Oval, Kennington | 2000 | f45237 |
| JEC Franklin | for Gloucestershire | College Ground, Cheltenham | 2009 | f51652 |
| Danish Kaneria | for Essex | County Ground, Derby | 2009 | f51747 |
| TS Roland-Jones | for Middlesex | Lord's Cricket Ground, St John's Wood | 2013 | f54803 |
| GJ Batty | for Surrey | The Kia Oval, Kennington | 2015 | f56512 |
