| 6 | KJ Wadsworth | v New South Wales | Sydney Cricket Ground, Sydney | 1969/70 | a282 |
| 5 | AC Parore | v West Indies | Nehru Stadium, Fatorda, Margao | 1994/95 | a8863 |
| 5 | BB McCullum | v India | McLean Park, Napier | 2002/03 | a14810 |
| 5 | BB McCullum | v India | Jade Stadium, Christchurch | 2002/03 | a14816 |
| 5 | BB McCullum | v South Africa | McLean Park, Napier | 2003/04 | a15786 |
| 5 | BB McCullum | v FICA World XI | Westpac Park, Hamilton | 2004/05 | a16408 |
| 5 | GJ Hopkins | v Ireland | Mannofield Park, Aberdeen | 2008 | a19056 |
| 5 | BB McCullum | v Bangladesh | McLean Park, Napier | 2009/10 | a20296 |
| 5 | BB McCullum | v Pakistan | Westpac Stadium, Wellington | 2010/11 | a21057 |
| 5 | TWM Latham | v Australia | Eden Park, Auckland | 2016/17 | a25116 |
| 5 | TWM Latham | v Afghanistan | The Cooper Associates County Ground, Taunton | 2019 | a27407 |
| 4 | WK Lees | v Australia | Sydney Cricket Ground, Sydney | 1982/83 | a3602 |
| 4 | AC Parore | v Pakistan | McLean Park, Napier | 1992/93 | a7861 |
| 4 | TE Blain | v South Africa | Bellerive Oval, Hobart | 1993/94 | a8400 |
| 4 | LK Germon | v Sri Lanka | Sharjah Cricket Association Stadium, Sharjah | 1996/97 | a10176 |
| 4 | LK Germon | v England | Basin Reserve, Wellington | 1996/97 | a10397 |
| 4 | AC Parore | v West Indies | WestpacTrust Stadium, Wellington | 1999/00 | a12352 |
| 4 | BB McCullum | v Sri Lanka | Rangiri Dambulla International Stadium, Dambulla | 2003 | a15119 |
| 4 | BB McCullum | v Pakistan | Rangiri Dambulla International Stadium, Dambulla | 2003 | a15124 |
| 4 | BB McCullum | v Zimbabwe | Harare Sports Club, Harare | 2005/06 | a16820 |
| 4 | BB McCullum | v England | Beausejour Stadium, Gros Islet | 2006/07 | a18093 |
| 4 | BB McCullum | v West Indies | Sir Vivian Richards Stadium, North Sound | 2006/07 | a18154 |
| 4 | BB McCullum | v Bangladesh | Bir Shrestha Shahid Ruhul Amin Stadium, Chittagong | 2008/09 | a19187 |
| 4 | BB McCullum | v England | Bidvest Wanderers Stadium, Johannesburg | 2009/10 | a20016 |
| 4 | GJ Hopkins | v India | Rangiri Dambulla International Stadium, Dambulla | 2010 | a20728 |
| 4 | BB McCullum | v Zimbabwe | Harare Sports Club, Harare | 2011/12 | a21549 |
| 4 | BB McCullum | v Bangladesh | Shere Bangla National Stadium, Mirpur | 2013/14 | a22948 |
| 4 | L Ronchi | v Pakistan | Eden Park, Auckland | 2015/16 | a24627 |
| 4 | TL Seifert | v Sri Lanka | Bay Oval, Mount Maunganui | 2018/19 | a26966 |
| 4 | TWM Latham | v West Indies | Emirates Old Trafford, Manchester | 2019 | a27429 |
