| 9 | Old Alleynians v Radley Rangers | Radley College Bigside Ground, Abingdon | 2025 |
| 8 | Old Alleynians v Old Merchant Taylors | Durrants Sports Ground, Croxley Green | 1969 |
| 8 | Old Alleynians v Rugby Meteors | Dulwich College Ground, Dulwich | 1973 |
| 8 | Old Alleynians v Oundle Rovers | Dulwich College Ground, Dulwich | 1981 |
| 7 | Old Alleynians v Haileybury Hermits | Haileybury College Ground, Hertford | 1970 |
| 7 | Old Alleynians v Stowe Templars | Stowe School Ground, Stowe | 1981 |
| 7 | Old Alleynians v Eton Ramblers | Agar's Plough, Eton College | 1984 |
| 7 | Old Alleynians v Old Westminsters | Dulwich College Ground, Dulwich | 2005 |
| 7 | Old Alleynians v Felsted Robins | Old Alleynians Ground, Dulwich Common | 2008 |
| 7 | Old Alleynians v Charterhouse Friars | Charterhouse School, Godalming | 2009 |
| 7 | Old Alleynians v Old Wellingtonians | Dulwich College Ground, Dulwich | 2024 |
| 6 | Old Alleynians v Old Cheltonians | College Ground, Cheltenham | 1972 |
| 6 | Old Alleynians v Felsted Robins | Dulwich College Ground, Dulwich | 1973 |
| 6 | Old Alleynians v Old Cheltonians | College Ground, Cheltenham | 1974 |
| 6 | Old Alleynians v Bradfield Waifs | Bradfield College, Reading | 1978 |
| 6 | Old Alleynians v Uppingham Rovers | Dulwich College Ground, Dulwich | 1979 |
| 6 | Old Alleynians v Old Malvernians | Dulwich College Ground, Dulwich | 1982 |
| 6 | Old Alleynians v Bradfield Waifs | Dulwich College Ground, Dulwich | 1988 |
| 6 | Old Alleynians v Eton Ramblers | Dulwich College Ground, Dulwich | 1990 |
| 6 | Old Alleynians v Old Cliftonians | Clifton College Close Ground, Clifton | 1993 |
| 6 | Old Alleynians v Old Malvernians | Dulwich College Ground, Dulwich | 1995 |
| 6 | Old Alleynians v St Edward's Martyrs | Dulwich College Ground, Dulwich | 2010 |
| 6 | Old Alleynians v Charterhouse Friars | Charterhouse School, Godalming | 2014 |
| 6 | Old Alleynians v Old Wykehamists | Dulwich College Ground, Dulwich | 2015 |
| 6 | Old Alleynians v Old Cranleighans | Jubilee, Cranleigh School | 2019 |
| 5 | Old Alleynians v Lancing Rovers | Lancing College Ground, Lancing | 1969 |
| 5 | Old Alleynians v Bradfield Waifs | Bradfield College, Reading | 1974 |
| 5 | Old Alleynians v Old Tonbridgians | Tonbridge School Ground, Tonbridge | 1974 |
| 5 | Old Alleynians v Felsted Robins | Dulwich College Ground, Dulwich | 1975 |
| 5 | Old Alleynians v Charterhouse Friars | Dulwich College Ground, Dulwich | 1977 |
| 5 | Old Alleynians v Old Merchant Taylors | Durrants Sports Ground, Croxley Green | 1983 |
| 5 | Old Alleynians v Haileybury Hermits | Dulwich College Ground, Dulwich | 1984 |
| 5 | Old Alleynians v Charterhouse Friars | Dulwich College Ground, Dulwich | 1984 |
| 5 | Old Alleynians v Old Malvernians | Dulwich College Ground, Dulwich | 1985 |
| 5 | Old Alleynians v Old Whitgiftians | Croham Manor Road, Croydon | 1990 |
| 5 | Old Alleynians v Repton Pilgrims | Repton School Ground, Repton | 1994 |
| 5 | Old Alleynians v Lancing Rovers | Dulwich College Ground, Dulwich | 1999 |
| 5 | Old Alleynians v Old Merchant Taylors | Dulwich College Ground, Dulwich | 2001 |
| 5 | Old Alleynians v Old Tonbridgians | Tonbridge School Ground, Tonbridge | 2006 |
| 5 | Old Alleynians v Marlborough Blues | Dulwich College Trevor Bailey Sports Ground, Dulwich Common | 2008 |
| 5 | Old Alleynians v Old Cranleighans | Jubilee, Cranleigh School | 2008 |
| 5 | Old Alleynians v Old Tonbridgians | Dulwich College Ground, Dulwich | 2017 |
